Tag Archives: khalwat

G25: “Some Ulama Consider Khalwat Raids Un-Islamic”

In its article, “Khalwat Raids Make Malaysia Tougher Than Saudi Arabia”, Free Malaysia Today (FMT) wrote:

The way Malaysian religious authorities are policing khalwat (close proximity) is beyond anything in Saudi Arabia or other Gulf States today, warns a leading NGO. – FMT

FMT was reporting on comments made by G25 adviser Tan Sri Mohd Sheriff Kassim, “in response to the recent death and injuries of two policemen who jumped from buildings to escape raids by the Selangor Islamic Religious Department (Jais).”

Birds of a feather flock together, like the G25’s spokesperson Dato Noor Farida Ariffin, Tan Sri Mohd Sheriff Kassim is also against khalwat raids.

Below are my answers (in blue) to FMT’s article (in red) regarding this issue.

G25 adviser Mohd Sheriff Kassim points out that even Saudi Arabia, the country which is home to Islam’s holiest site, has issued stern guidelines to limit the powers of the moral police to harass and arrest Muslims.

“The instruction is that the moral police should not take the law into their own hands and instead, it should advise those committing offences under the morality laws to change and repent,” he said In a statement today.

I cannot comment on the laws of Saudi Arabia because

  1. I have not studied the laws of the country

  2. I respect and do not want to interfere with the laws of the land.

But even if it is true that they do not implement such laws, as a sovereign country, we have our own constitutional rights to implement our own laws.

Anyway, if G25 adviser thinks that Saudi Arabia is doing a better job in dealing with Syariah offences, then G25 must fight for our country to follow the laws of Saudi Arabia, which means implementing the Hudud laws in our country.

 His comments were in response to the recent death and injuries of two policemen who jumped from buildings to escape raids by the Selangor Islamic Religious Department (Jais).

As policemen, they must know the laws and their rights, so if they chose to jump from the building in order to escape, the fault is theirs and it is not JAIS’ fault.

Would G25 blame the police if a burglar chose to jump from a building in order to avoid being arrested by the policemen who are carrying their duties? 

Just two months ago, Jais introduced a mobile phone app, called “Hotline Jais”, for people to report religious offences, including khalwat.

It is a good move by JAIS to use updated technology so that it is easier for the public to report religious offences in order for us to take care of our Muslim community.

Sheriff added that Malays who visited or lived in Arab states have not come across any country where so-called moral police raid private homes.

If we must follow the laws of Saudi Arabia, we must change our Federal Constitution and implement the Hudud laws.

He also pointed out that some ulama consider khalwat raids un-Islamic as it gave the impression that the religion used only punishment to uphold morals.

Khalwat raid is one of the ways to prevent the religious offence of khalwat and the Islamic authorities have their Standard Operating Procedure that must be followed by their enforcement officers conducting the raids, only liberal ‘ulama’ would declare that our khalwat raids are un-Islamic; not the real ulama of Ahli As-Sunnah Wa Al-Jamaah.

Khalwat raids also tended to target the lower-income group as the “rich and powerful” had more resources to “get away with bigger sins”. Sheriff noted that khalwat laws could be easily exploited by a person’s enemies to “settle a score”.

G25 adviser has made a very serious allegation which I hope he has the proves to support it, and it is the duty of G25 to make police reports as soon as possible regarding this matter.

“Our authorities should learn from the failed experience of dictatorial regimes which criminalised personal thoughts and behaviour to discourage individualism and promote mass obedience to the state ideology,” he said.

What does khalwat raid have to do with “dictatorial regimes which criminalised personal thoughts and behaviour to discourage individualism and promote mass obedience to the state ideology”?

Islamic matters are not political matters and it is stated clearly in our Federal Constitution that the YDP Agong and the Royal Rulers are the Head of Islam, so the above statement is a malicious distortion of the truth and a humiliation to the Royal Rulers.

Article 3(2) of the Federal Constitution:

In every State other than States not having a Ruler the position of the Ruler as the Head of the religion of Islam in his State in the manner and to the extent acknowledged and declared by the Constitution of that State, and, subject to that Constitution, all rights, privileges, prerogatives and powers enjoyed by him as Head of that religion, are unaffected and unimpaired; but in any acts, observances or ceremonies with respect to which the Conference of Rulers has agreed that they should extend to the Federation as a whole each of the other Rulers shall in his capacity of Head of the religion of Islam authorize the Yang di-Pertuan Agong to represent him.

Article 3(3) of the Federal Constitution:

The Constitution of the States of Malacca, Penang, Sabah and Sarawak shall each make provision for conferring on the Yang di-Pertuan Agong the position of Head of the religion of Islam in that State.

Since G25 wants us to follow Saudi Arabia, G25 members must start fighting for our country to implement Hudud.

Related Posts:

Datuk Noor Farida And G25 Must Go Back To School

Moderation in Islam means wasatiyyah and not being liberal as understood by G25.

G25 members who are trying to teach other Muslims about moderation in Islam must seek advises from Global Movement of Moderates Foundation (GMM) to understand what is ‘moderation’ in Islam. 

In its latest attack on the Islamic authorities of Malaysia, G25 wants the punishment for ‘khalwat’ to be repeal on the ground of “those are personal sins”; and in response to the statement, Mufti Perak, Tan Sri Dr. Harussani Zakaria adviced G25 to “bertaubat”.

Below are my answers (in blue) to Free Malaysia Today (FMT)’s article (in red) regarding this issue.

PETALING JAYA: A “personal sin” like khalwat (close proximity) is between the couple involved and God and should not be treated like a crime punishable by the state, said the G25 movement of Malay moderates.

Speaking on their behalf was Noor Farida Ariffin, who was quoted by The Rakyat Post as saying, “Those are personal sins. It’s a sin against God. Between that person and God.”

Does Datuk Noor Farida mean to say that khalwat is just “personal sin” and is not punishable by the State according to the Islamic laws? Now, is she trying to liberalise the Islamic laws or she knows nothing about the Islamic laws? Datuk Noor Farida must understand that the Islamic laws cannot be changed. Muslims must live according to the rules of Islam and not the other way around.

Khalwat is against the Islamic laws, so it is punishable by the State in Malaysia because as an Islamic country, Muslims in this country are also governed by the Islamic personal law as written by The Right Honourable Tan Sri Dato’ Seri Md Raus bin Sharif in the Federal Court judgement of the case, ZI Publications Sdn Bhd and Another v Kerajaan Negeri Selangor:

“Federal Constitution allows the Legislature of a State to legislate and enact offences against the precepts of Islam. Taking the Federal Constitution as a whole, it is clear that it was the intention of the framers of our Constitution to allow Muslims in this country to be also governed by Islamic personal law”.

In Malaysia, we have the Syariah Court that deals with the Islamic laws, and it has the jurisdiction upon every Muslim in this country. 

Questioning why it was turned into a crime, she added, “Islam says you could not intrude on personal space.”

Datuk Noor Farida Ariffin, who does not understand Islam and the Islamic laws should not speak about matters that she knows nothing about. Rather than making her own conclusion and judgement about khalwat and other Islamic laws, she should go to JAKIM and ask for help to guide her to the right path of Islam. She really needs help.

She said this at a press conference after a G25 forum on “Islam in a Constitutional Democracy” and noted that Malaysia was the only country in the world that punished those involved in khalwat.

Datuk Noor Farida must do her homework. Countries that observe the Islamic laws in their legal systems, will punish those involved in khalwat, for example Saudi Arabia and Brunei. 

“This is against Islam. You cannot knock at a person’s door at 3am and arrest people.”

Does she mean that actions taken by the Islamic authorities against khalwat (that is against the Islamic law) is against Islam? She is really confused between what are the rights and wrongs in Islam. It is her statements that is actually against Islam.

She also said there was a need to review other syariah laws that trespassed on the Federal Constitution and pointed out that even non-Muslims were being affected by the Islamic law presently.

All the Articles in the Federal Constitution are harmoniously with each other. The Syariah laws does not trespassed the Federal Constitution because the Article 3(1) states that Islam is the religion of the Federation, hence the other Articles in the Federal Constitution must be read harmoniously with Article 3(1).

In fact, the Federal Constitution recognises the Syariah Court as stated in the Article 121(1)(1a) of the Federal Constitution:

121. (1) There shall be two High Courts of co-ordinate jurisdiction and status, namely—

(a) one in the States of Malaya, which shall be known as the High Court in Malaya and shall have its principal registry at such place in the States of Malaya as the Yang di-Pertuan Agong may determine; and

(b) one in the States of Sabah and Sarawak, which shall be known as the High Court in Sabah and Sarawak and shall have its principal registry at such place in the States of Sabah and Sarawak as the Yang di-Pertuan Agong may determine;

(1a) The courts referred to in Clause (1) shall have no jurisdiction in respect of any matter within the jurisdiction of the Syariah courts.

The Syariah laws only govern the Muslims and does not affect the non-Muslims.

She cited the incidents of dead bodies being snatched for Muslim burials and custody issues when one spouse converts to Islam and explained, “This is the kind of injustices we want to prevent.

Datuk Noor Farida must get her facts rights. This is a malicious distortion of truth used again and again to undermine the Islamic religious authorities even after the Islamic religious authorities had answered the accusations. When the Islamic authorities receive a report, it is their duty to investigate and to take proper actions to solve the problems.

“The way Islam is being implemented under syariah law is resulting in a lot of injustice to Muslims and non-Muslims.

Datuk Noor Farida must learn more about Islam and the implementation of the syariah laws in Malaysia before making more silly statements. Only the Muslims who do not love their religion and do not want Islam as the way of life are against the implementation of the Syariah laws in their countries.

“This is why people are saying that Islam has been hijacked by state authorities,” she said, adding that the way it was being interpreted did not uphold the values of Islam as a religion of justice, mercy and compassion.

People made all kinds of statements and accusations regarding matters which are not agreeable to them; so Datuk Noor Farida must specify who are the people who made the above statements.

She must mix around with more Muslims and attend programs organised by Islamic groups rather than only making friends with the people who subscribe to the liberal ideology in order to see things straight. 



Tan Sri Harussani Saran G25 Bertaubat

I’ve written a few articles answering G25’s malicious attacks on the Islamic authorities and the government of Malaysia:

  1. Reaksi Jurucakap G25 Terhadap Bersih 4 Menyedihkan
  2. G25, Another Voice Of Liberal Muslims
  3. Tawfik Tun Dr Ismail Wants Jakim Abolished
  4. Bila Liberal Mengajar Apa Itu Islam

(UTUSAN) Lumut 7 Dis. – Kumpulan bekas penjawat awam yang menggelar diri mereka sebagai G25 disaran segera bertaubat kerana tindakan ‘cuba’ meminda atau memansuhkan undang-undang syariah yang didakwa bertentangan dengan Perlembagaan negara boleh membawa kepada murtad.

Saranan itu disuarakan Mufti Perak, Tan Sri Dr. Harussani Zakaria yang menyifatkan bahawa hasrat kumpulan itu mahu memansuhkan beberapa undang-undang syariah sama seperti menentang hukum Islam dan juga Allah.

Harussani juga menganggap gerakan itu sebagai ancaman kepada umat Islam dan menegaskan bahawa umat Islam boleh jatuh kufur sekiranya ‘keluar’ daripada perintah Allah.

Menurutnya, jika kata khalwat itu adalah hak asasi manusia, kalau begitu, mencuri pun hak asasi manusia juga, bebas untuk mencuri, begitu juga dengan membunuh.

“Pada saya gerakan ini kelihatan seperti kumpulan orang-orang yang putus asa, mungkin kerana mereka tidak diberi kesempatan atau peluang selepas pencen, sebab itu cari jalan ini.

“Saya minta kumpulan ini bertaubatlah dan buat kerja amal yang lebih baik daripada kita mahu rosakkan agama, pecah-belahkan umat Islam. Lebih baik mereka buat persatuan menggunakan kebijaksanaan untuk membantu perkara-perkara yang membangunkan umat. Janganlah kita terbawa-bawa dengan budaya Barat,” katanya.

Beliau berkata demikian ketika ditemui selepas menghadiri program Bicara Bersama Mufti di Samudera di Jeti Pangkalan Tentera Laut Diraja Malaysia (TLDM) di sini, hari ini.

Semalam, G25 mahu penubuhan sebuah jawatankuasa perunding bagi membincangkan untuk meminda atau memansuhkan beberapa undang-undang syariah termasuk hukuman terhadap perbuatan berkhalwat yang didakwa melanggar hak kebebasan seseorang seperti termaktub di dalam Perlembagaan.

Jurucakap G25, Datuk Noor Farida Ariffin berkata, dengan berpandukan pada prinsip Perlembagaan, kumpulan tersebut menentang sebarang hukuman terhadap perbuatan khalwat jika dilakukan di rumah persendirian kerana itu adalah hak dan privasi setiap individu.

Dalam pada itu, Mufti Kelantan, Datuk Mohammad Shukri Mohammad ketika dihubungi menegaskan, tindakan kumpulan itu mengangkat perjuangan hak privasi individu menggambarkan seolah-olah mereka membelakangkan hak yang lebih agung iaitu hak Tuhan.

Katanya, hak Tuhan perlu diperjuangkan terlebih dahulu, kecuali seseorang itu tidak mempercayai wujudnya Tuhan.

“Undang-undang khalwat ini dibuat sebagai mekanisme membasmi kemungkaran dalam masyarakat. Tindakan dalam mencegah kemungkaran ini sememangnya adalah peraturan Islam.

“Kita juga ada hak masyarakat. Bagaimana hendak asingkan hak individu dengan hak masyarakat sedangkan kita semua hidup dalam satu rangkaian tanggungjawab kepada satu sama lain?” soalnya.

Sementara itu, Mufti Negeri Sembilan, Datuk Mohd. Yusof Ahmad berkata, prinsip Perlembagaan tidak mengatasi al-Quran kerana Kalam Allah itu mengatasi segala-galanya.

Tegasnya, telah termaktub dalam Perlembagaan yang turut menetapkan Islam adalah agama rasmi Persekutuan.

“Jadi bagaimana pula khalwat itu dikatakan perkara peribadi dan tidak boleh dijadikan sebagai jenayah? Kumpulan bekas penjawat awam (G25) bercakap tanpa pengetahuan tentang jenayah Islam yang ditetapkan oleh al-Quran.

“Mereka perlu meneliti dan mendalami jenayah Islam dan bila tidak tahu, mulalah bercakap ikut hukum akal, walhal (hukuman) memang sudah termaktub dalam hukum syarak,” tegasnya.

Dalam pada itu, Mufti Pulau Pinang, Datuk Dr. Wan Salim Wan Mohd. Noor meminta G25 tidak terlalu ghairah meniru gaya hidup masyarakat Barat yang terlalu bebas sehingga hilangnya nilai-nilai moral dalam kehidupan.

Beliau berkata, peraturan yang termaktub dalam Enakmen Pentadbiran Agama Islam Negeri-Negeri di Malaysia dan undang-undang syariah yang diguna pakai adalah bagi memelihara kesejahteraan umat Islam di negara ini daripada perkara-perkara merosakkan termasuk perbuatan berkhalwat.

Tegas beliau, sekiranya kehidupan umat Islam di negara ini tidak lagi berlandaskan nilai-nilai moral dan prinsip berakhlak murni, keutuhan negara akan tergugat, sekali gus menjadikan kehidupan masyarakat menjadi kucar-kacir.

Katanya, kumpulan ini amat terpengaruh dengan pemikiran liberal Barat dan bernostalgiakan zaman penjajahan lalu yang meminggirkan agama serta budaya tempatan.

“Sepatutnya mereka memanfaatkan kesempatan yang ada setelah bersara untuk mendalami pengetahuan agama dan beribadat demi persediaan serta bekalan di akhirat kelak.

“Tidak sepatutnya masa yang ada ini dibazirkan dengan menimbulkan isu-isu yang aneh, janggal dan mengelirukan masyarakat. Jangan meracuni fikiran masyarakat dengan fahaman sendiri,” katanya ketika dihubungi di sini hari ini.

%d bloggers like this: